Bluesky: The Alternative to X

Public Original Author Jessica November 19, 2024

In the aftermath of the 2024 presidential election, a seismic shift is occurring in social media. Bluesky, once a modest Twitter-funded experiment, has exploded into the fastest-growing social network of 2024. With over 18 million users and growing by approximately 10,000 every 10-15 minutes, the platform has become the digital refuge for those seeking an alternative to Elon Musk’s X (formerly Twitter). The platform’s name and branding are very similar to Twitter, contrasting X’s darker space aesthetic with the optimistic imagery of blue skies and simple butterfly logo.

The catalyst for this extraordinary growth wasn’t just happenstance. Following Donald Trump’s election victory and the subsequent announcement of Elon Musk’s appointment to lead a government efficiency department, many X users began seeking alternatives. The Guardian’s high-profile departure from X, citing concerns about far-right conspiracy theories and racism, became a watershed moment, leading to what many are calling the Great X-odus.

From Twitter’s Lab to Independent Platform

The Bluesky story begins in 2019 when then-Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey announced a research project to decentralize Twitter. What makes this origin story particularly fascinating is how Twitter essentially funded its future competition with $13 million and a single condition: develop technologies for open and decentralized public conversation.

Under the leadership of CEO Jay Graber, who negotiated for six months to ensure the platform’s independence, Bluesky evolved from a research initiative into a Public Benefit Corporation. This foresight proved crucial when Elon Musk acquired Twitter in 2022, as Bluesky’s autonomous status protected it from the sweeping changes that would later affect X.

Technical Innovation and Engineering Culture

Behind Bluesky’s rapid rise lies a fascinating technical architecture and engineering culture that sets it apart from traditional social media platforms. The company operates with a remarkably lean team of just 40 full-time staff, including 12 software engineers in the core team. What makes this engineering team particularly unique is its unusually high ratio of former founders, with approximately 80% of the core team having previously founded their own companies.

The platform’s technical foundation combines TypeScript for most operations with Go for performance-critical components. This technical decision enables rapid development and easy scaling while maintaining code quality. Perhaps most impressively, the entire mobile and web application was initially built by a single developer using React Native and Expo, demonstrating the efficiency of their engineering approach.

Feature Set and User Experience

Bluesky’s approach to user experience represents a fundamental shift from traditional social media. The platform supports approximately 50,000 different interest-based feeds, all operating without algorithmic manipulation. Unlike X and Meta’s platforms, Bluesky maintains a strictly chronological feed, giving users complete control over their content consumption.

Posts on Bluesky, called “skeets,” are limited to 256 characters and can include images and videos. The platform’s blocking features have become a major selling point, especially in contrast to X’s controversial changes that make blocked users’ posts visible to all. This commitment to user control extends to data privacy, with Bluesky pledging not to train AI models on user content.

The Growing Ecosystem

As Bluesky matures, it’s fostering a vibrant ecosystem of third-party applications that enhance the user experience. Deck Blue has emerged as a powerful TweetDeck alternative, offering multi-column views and advanced features for power users. Mac users have Sky.app, which provides native integration and keyboard shortcuts, while cross-posting tools like Croissant ($2.99/month) help users manage their presence across multiple platforms.

For mobile users, alternatives like Graysky and Skeets offer enhanced features such as custom feeds, translation services, and advanced bookmarking capabilities. This growing ecosystem of third-party apps demonstrates the platform’s commitment to openness and user choice, a stark contrast to X’s restrictions on third-party clients.

The Celebrity Migration

The platform has attracted an impressive roster of high-profile users, including Mark Hamill, Guillermo Del Toro, Stephen King, Rachel Maddow, and dozens more celebrities and public figures. Media organizations like The Guardian have also established a presence, bringing their substantial audiences with them.

This migration of cultural influencers suggests a potential long-term transformation in how public figures engage with social media. The atmosphere on Bluesky is often compared to Twitter’s earlier days, particularly around 2012-2014, when the platform was considered more conducive to meaningful discourse and community building.

Business Model and Future Sustainability

Unlike traditional social media companies, Bluesky operates as a Public Benefit Corporation (PBC), prioritizing public good over immediate profit. This unusual structure allows the company to focus on developing and promoting decentralized public conversation technologies without the immediate pressure of generating returns for shareholders.

The platform has begun exploring innovative revenue streams that align with its decentralized vision, such as partnering with Namecheap to sell custom domains. This approach represents a departure from traditional social media monetization strategies that rely heavily on advertising and user data exploitation.

Navigating Political Waters

A question many ask is how Elon Musk, known for his robust responses to competitors, has remained notably quiet about Bluesky’s surge. Industry analysts suggest his silence may be attributed to his intense focus on post-election responsibilities and his new role in government efficiency initiatives with the Trump administration. Additionally, the unique circumstance of Bluesky’s funding – secured before Musk’s Twitter acquisition – creates an awkward dynamic that may be contributing to his uncharacteristic restraint.

Despite being characterized by some as left-leaning, Bluesky’s technical infrastructure decisions appear to be purely merit-based. The platform utilizes a diverse range of open-source technologies without showing preference for or against any particular corporate technology providers. This technical neutrality stands in contrast to the platform’s user base, which has notably skewed toward those dissatisfied with X’s rightward shift under Musk.

Scaling Challenges and Solutions

The platform’s rapid growth hasn’t come without challenges. Bluesky has experienced periods of slowness and downtime as it struggles to accommodate its expanding user base. However, the engineering team’s approach to these challenges reveals their technical sophistication – at one point running 192 Node processes behind HAProxy with merely 1% CPU utilization, demonstrating their ability to scale efficiently with minimal resources.

Content moderation at scale presents another significant challenge, particularly as the platform attempts to maintain its commitment to decentralized governance while preventing the spread of harmful content. The company addresses this through a combination of automated tools and human moderation, with a team of approximately 20 people dedicated to support and moderation tasks.

Community Dynamics and Culture

The influx of new users has created what the company describes as an eternal September problem, where longtime users worry about the potential dilution of the platform’s unique culture. The term refers to the period when AOL began offering Usenet access to its users, leading to an endless September of new users learning community norms.

To address these concerns, Bluesky is developing more sophisticated content moderation tools and introducing features that allow users to customize their experience more extensively. The platform’s commitment to user autonomy extends to community management, where users can create and moderate their own servers with distinct rules and guidelines.

Looking to the Future

As Bluesky continues its rapid growth, several key questions remain about its long-term sustainability and impact on the social media:

Critical Questions:

1. Can Bluesky maintain its user-first approach while achieving financial sustainability?
2. How will the platform balance decentralization with the need for platform-wide standards?
3. Will the absence of algorithmic curation prove sustainable as the user base grows?
4. Can the platform retain its current culture while scaling to hundreds of millions of users?
5. How will Elon Musk and X respond to Bluesky’s continued growth?

Conclusion

Bluesky’s rise represents more than just another social media success story – it’s a testament to the demand for alternatives to traditional, centralized platforms. Its commitment to user privacy, decentralization, and community-driven development offers a glimpse of what the future of social media might look like.

Whether Bluesky can maintain its momentum and successfully navigate the challenges ahead remains to be seen. However, its rapid growth and passionate user base suggest that its approach to social networking has struck a chord with users seeking a more thoughtful, controlled, and community-oriented online experience.

Key Points:

  • 18M+ users with 1M new users daily post-2024 election
  • Founded by Twitter with $13M, now independent
  • Decentralized platform with unique AT Protocol
  •  Growing ecosystem of third-party apps
  • Led by CEO Jay Graber with a very lean team
  • No algorithmic feed manipulation
  • Strong focus on user privacy and control
  • Attracting major celebrities and media outlets
  • Top-ranked social app on Apple’s App Store
  • Novel business model as Public Benefit Corporation

References

  • Forbes Technology Report (2024)
    Title: “What To Know About Bluesky—The Buzzy Social Media App Siphoning Users From Elon Musk’s X”
    URL: forbes.com/sites/conormurray/2024/11/14/what-to-know-about-bluesky/
  • TechCrunch Platform Analysis (2024)
    Title: “Bluesky is having a moment — a moment that’s already stretched on for nearly three months”
    URL: techcrunch.com/2024/11/14/bluesky-social-network-growth/
  • Inside Bluesky’s Engineering Culture (2024)
    Title: “Inside Bluesky’s Engineering Culture: A deep dive into how a fully remote, open source-first, tech company is building a challenger social media platform”
    URL: pragmaticengineer.com/blog/inside-bluesky-engineering/
  • Lifehacker App Ecosystem Review (2024)
    Title: “Yes, There Is a TweetDeck for Bluesky – The Best Bluesky Clients You Can Use Right Now”
    URL: lifehacker.com/yes-there-is-a-tweetdeck-for-bluesky-1851079234/
  • Ground News Platform Comparison (2024)
    Title: “Bluesky Emerges as a Leading Alternative to Elon Musk’s X”
    URL: ground.news/article/bluesky-platform-analysis-2024/
  • The Guardian Digital Analysis (2024)
    Title: “Why The Guardian is leaving X: Our decision to quit the platform formerly known as Twitter”
    URL: theguardian.com/technology/2024/nov/why-the-guardian-is-leaving-x/
  • CNBC Social Media Market Analysis (2024)
    Title: “Bluesky hits 18 million users as X alternatives gain momentum post-election”
    URL: cnbc.com/2024/11/social-media-landscape-bluesky-growth/
  • Protocol Lab Technical Documentation (2024)
    Title: “AT Protocol: Technical Specifications and Implementation Guide”
    URL: atproto.com/docs/specifications/
  • JustJared Celebrity Migration Report (2024)
    Title: “Every Star Who Left X for Bluesky – Dozens of Celebs Move to Rival Social Media Platform”
    URL: justjared.com/2024/11/celebrities-joining-bluesky/
  • Digital Privacy Coalition Assessment (2024)
    Title: “Social Media Privacy Analysis: Bluesky’s Approach to User Data Protection”
    URL: digitalprivacycoalition.org/reports/bluesky-privacy-2024/